perm filename FPRINT.TIM[TIM,LSP] blob
sn#772851 filedate 1984-10-08 generic text, type C, neo UTF8
COMMENT ⊗ VALID 00019 PAGES
C REC PAGE DESCRIPTION
C00001 00001
C00002 00002 SAIL
C00004 00003 Fprint
C00005 00004 NIL
C00008 00005 Franz
C00016 00006 SCORE Dec 12, 1983
C00017 00007 DEC780CL
C00018 00008 InterLisp Vax 780
C00019 00009 PSL-20 3.3
C00020 00010 PSL-Cray 3.2
C00022 00011 PSL-750 3.2
C00023 00012 PSL-780 3.2
C00024 00013 PSL-DN600 3.2
C00025 00014 PSL-DN300 3.2
C00026 00015 PSL-dn160
C00027 00016 PERQ 6/19/84
C00028 00017 PSL Numbers 7/31/84
C00029 00018 LMI/Tyson 15-Aug-84 1920
C00030 00019 PSL-3081
C00031 ENDMK
C⊗;
;;; SAIL
(fasload fprint)
(timit)
Timing performed on Monday 09/13/82 at 11:56:15.
Cpu Time = 0.901
Elapsed Time = 3.53333333
Wholine Time = 1.83333333
GC Time = 0.0
Load Average Before = 2.06104112
Load Average After = 2.0700469
Average Load Average = 2.065544
NIL
Timing performed on Monday 09/13/82 at 11:56:23.
Cpu Time = 0.897
Elapsed Time = 4.55
Wholine Time = 1.8
GC Time = 0.0
Load Average Before = 2.02221072
Load Average After = 2.00235736
Average Load Average = 2.01228404
NIL
Timing performed on Monday 09/13/82 at 11:56:31.
Cpu Time = 0.888
Elapsed Time = 6.5
Wholine Time = 2.5
GC Time = 0.475
Load Average Before = 1.99930274
Load Average After = 1.97900426
Average Load Average = 1.9891535
NIL
;;; New SAIL (RPO7)
Timing performed on Wednesday 10/12/83 at 23:26:18.
Cpu (- GC) Time = 0.78
Elapsed Time = 9.1833333
Wholine Time = 1.31666666
GC Time = 0.402
Load Average Before = 1.54794335
Load Average After = 1.60265815
Average Load Average = 1.57530075
NIL
;;; Fprint
D3
7/5/83
Local disk
Elapsed 2.93
Dsk io 1.15
CPU 1.78
dskops 186
D2
7/5/83
Local disk, without interrupts
Elapsed 14.9
Swap 2.56
Dsk io 2.63
CPU 9.7
pgflts 101
dskops 222
D1
1/25/84 with interrupts local disk, Shugart
Elapsed 13.7
CPU 13.3
GC .4
;;; NIL
FPRINT
Fixnum arithmetic.
Hmmm. I think i may have just found a bug in the charpos-manipulator
mixin for output streams which causes it, when the charpos exceeds
the line length (default 80), to go searching hopelessly for a
line-wrap method. At the same time not resetting the charpos (after
all, the line did not wrap), so doing this on every character after
number 79.
I should add there is a sort of bug in benchmarking i/o in this manner
anyway for systems which do record i/o, line-oriented. If you give
super-long lines then it has to keep expanding the buffer, so you are
measuring that, rather than the i/o as it would "normally" occur.
In NIL this does not occur, because I have not upgraded the primitive
disk i/o support above the early primitives written in bliss. They
don't handle records longer than 512 bytes, so cheat by just writing
them out, and on reading, cheat by saying that if the record is
exactly 512 bytes long, then we don't insert the implicit newline at
the end of it. So for NIL at least read/print/read holds, i hope, as
i go to try FREAD...
So for whatever it is worth, the time for this was
cpu=131.93,elapsed=133.11,pagefaults=167
but i would not quote it.
Fixing the bug (it is a patch in the current distribution), we get:
cpu=37.92,elapsed=38.97,pagefaults=144
cpu=37.65,elapsed=38.23,pagefaults=4
NIL file i/o is yet another thing which is going to be replaced
totally. I believe i will be eliminating one Lisp function call and
maybe one other VAX procedure call per character output.
;;; Franz
∂09-Oct-83 1122 jkf@ucbkim fprint
Received: from UCBKIM by SU-AI with TCP/SMTP; 9 Oct 83 11:22:05 PDT
Received: by ucbkim.ARPA (4.6/4.2)
id AA18823; Sun, 9 Oct 83 11:25:33 PDT
Date: Sun, 9 Oct 83 11:25:33 PDT
From: John Foderaro (on an h19-u) <jkf@ucbkim>
Message-Id: <8310091825.AA18823@ucbkim.ARPA>
To: rpg@su-ai
Subject: fprint
Cc:
--- Benchmark fprint run on lbl-csam at Sun Oct 9 11:06:21 PDT 1983 by jkf
--- cpu usage: 11:06am up 2 days, 2:58, 2 users, load average: 1.15, 1.29, 1.28
Franz Lisp, Opus 38.81
-> [fasl fprint.o]
t
-> benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: on, localf: no
executing form: (fprint)
begin (68 179)
end (254 179)
runs 5
avg cpu time 0.62
benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: off, localf: no
executing form: (fprint)
begin (255 179)
end (445 179)
runs 5
avg cpu time 0.6333333333333333
nil
-> Franz Lisp, Opus 38.81
-> [fasl fprint-l.o]
t
-> benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: on, localf: yes
executing form: (fprint)
begin (57 182)
end (245 182)
runs 5
avg cpu time 0.6266666666666667
benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: off, localf: yes
executing form: (fprint)
begin (247 182)
end (439 182)
runs 5
avg cpu time 0.64
nil
-> Franz Lisp, Opus 38.81
-> [load fprint.l]
[fasl benchmac.o]
t
-> benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: on, interpreted
executing form: (fprint)
begin (970 664)
end (1160 664)
runs 5
avg cpu time 0.6333333333333333
benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: off, interpreted
executing form: (fprint)
begin (1163 664)
end (1359 664)
runs 5
avg cpu time 0.6533333333333333
nil
-> --- cpu usage: 11:07am up 2 days, 2:59, 2 users, load average: 1.15, 1.27, 1.27
--- end of benchmark fprint
--- Benchmark fprint run on ucbmatisse at Sun Oct 9 11:10:16 PDT 1983 by jkf
--- cpu usage: 11:10am up 1 day, 19:39, 3 users, load average: 1.47, 1.28, 1.14
Franz Lisp, Opus 38.81
=> [fasl fprint.o]
t
=> benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: on, localf: no
executing form: (fprint)
begin (155 208)
end (492 208)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.123333333333333
benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: off, localf: no
executing form: (fprint)
begin (496 208)
end (817 208)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.07
nil
=> Franz Lisp, Opus 38.81
=> [fasl fprint-l.o]
t
=> benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: on, localf: yes
executing form: (fprint)
begin (147 206)
end (480 206)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.11
benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: off, localf: yes
executing form: (fprint)
begin (482 206)
end (813 206)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.103333333333333
nil
=> Franz Lisp, Opus 38.81
=> [load fprint.l]
[fasl benchmac.o]
t
=> benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: on, interpreted
executing form: (fprint)
begin (1522 874)
end (1853 874)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.103333333333333
benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: off, interpreted
executing form: (fprint)
begin (1856 874)
end (2182 874)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.086666666666667
nil
=> --- cpu usage: 11:12am up 1 day, 19:40, 3 users, load average: 1.29, 1.28, 1.15
--- end of benchmark fprint
--- Benchmark fprint run on ucbmike at Sun Oct 9 10:52:39 PDT 1983 by jkf
--- cpu usage: 10:52am up 2 days, 1:24, 2 users, load average: 1.01, 1.01, 1.00
Franz Lisp, Opus 38.79
-> [fasl fprint.o]
t
-> benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: on, localf: no
executing form: (fprint)
begin (143 341)
end (571 341)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.426666666666667
benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: off, localf: no
executing form: (fprint)
begin (573 341)
end (1000 341)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.423333333333333
nil
-> Franz Lisp, Opus 38.79
-> [fasl fprint-l.o]
t
-> benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: on, localf: yes
executing form: (fprint)
begin (120 341)
end (547 341)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.423333333333333
benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: off, localf: yes
executing form: (fprint)
begin (551 341)
end (979 341)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.426666666666667
nil
-> Franz Lisp, Opus 38.79
-> [load fprint.l]
[fasl benchmac.o]
t
-> benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: on, interpreted
executing form: (fprint)
begin (729 412)
end (1155 412)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.42
benchmark: test (file fprint) , tranlinks: off, interpreted
executing form: (fprint)
begin (1160 412)
end (1589 412)
runs 5
avg cpu time 1.43
nil
-> --- cpu usage: 10:54am up 2 days, 1:26, 2 users, load average: 1.08, 1.05, 1.02
--- end of benchmark fprint
;;; SCORE Dec 12, 1983
not block compiled
4.451 seconds
0.0 gc
;;; DEC780CL
cpu + probability x gc
FPRINT 21
*************************************************************************
Name of VAXLisp VAXLisp VAXLisp VAXLisp
application U1.0-20 U1.0-20 U1.0-20 U1.0-20
Benchmark VMS V3.5 VMS V3.5 VMS V3.5 VMS V3.6
730 (No FPA) 750 (No FPA) 780 785 (No FPA)
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fprint 18.30 6.08 3.94 2.32
;;; InterLisp Vax 780
FPRINT:
←(TIME (FPRINT]
222 conses
0.752 seconds
/lisp/rbates/lisp/dick/FPRINT.TST;1
←LOAD(FPRINT.V]
compiled on 14-AUG-84 17:23:41
File Created: 5-JUL-83 14:29:33
FPRINTCOMS
/lisp/rbates/lisp/dick/FPRINT.V
←(TIME (FPRINT]
222 conses
0.608 seconds
;;; PSL-20 3.3
Fprint Test
Timing performed on DEC-20
23-Mar-84 05:08:21 .
........................................
Cpu (- GC) Time = 4.778 secs
Elapsed Time = 6.0 secs
GC Time = 0.0 secs
Load Average Before = 1.3
Load Average After = 1.3
Average Load Average = 1.3
;;; PSL-Cray 3.2
;;; Times are in milliseconds
08:50:22 008:16.452 Fprint Test$2 π
08:50:43 008:22.907 Cpu (- GC) Time = 3617.90000000 secs$2 ε
08:50:44 008:23.428 Elapsed Time = 0. secs
08:50:48 008:23.948 GC Time = 0. secs
08:50:51 008:24.468 Load Average Before = 0
08:50:53 008:24.988 Load Average After = 0
08:50:55 008:25.509 Average Load Average = 0.
| KL-10b | 20-60 | 20-60 | 3600 | 20-60 | CRAY | NEW
Benchmark |MACLISP |InterLisp| PSL 3.2| ZetaL | PSL 3.3 | PSL 3.2| PSL 3.2
------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fprint | 0.78 | 4.451 | 4.665 | 3.1 | 4.636 | 3.618 | 0.378
;;; PSL-750 3.2
Cpu (- GC) Time = 5.338 secs
Elapsed Time = 0.0 secs
GC Time = 0.0 secs
Load Average Before = 0
Load Average After = 0
Average Load Average = 0.0
;;; PSL-780 3.2
Cpu (- GC) Time = 2.193 secs
Elapsed Time = 0.0 secs
GC Time = 0.0 secs
Load Average Before = 0
Load Average After = 0
Average Load Average = 0.0
;;; PSL-DN600 3.2
Cpu (- GC) Time = 4.43 secs
Elapsed Time = 0.0 secs
GC Time = 0.0 secs
Load Average Before = 0
Load Average After = 0
Average Load Average = 0.0
;;; PSL-DN300 3.2
Cpu (- GC) Time = 4.191 secs
Elapsed Time = 0.0 secs
GC Time = 0.0 secs
Load Average Before = 0
Load Average After = 0
Average Load Average = 0.0
;;; PSL-dn160
Fprint Test
Timing performed on Apollo
today 12:00:00.
........................................
Cpu (- GC) Time = 1.891 secs
Elapsed Time = 0.0 secs
GC Time = 0.0 secs
Load Average Before = 0
Load Average After = 0
Average Load Average = 0.0
;;; PERQ 6/19/84
16.38 seconds (stopwatch)
7/31/84
Benchmark % of old time Time Machine used
Fprint 16.38 RPG's T2
Fprint 20.0
;;; PSL Numbers 7/31/84
|KL-10b| 20-60 | 20-60 | 3600 | 20-60 | CRAY | 12Mhz| HP-UX
Benchmark |MACLSP|InterLsp|PSL 3.2| ZetaL|PSL 3.3|PSL3.2| HP200|PSL3.3
--------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fprint | 0.78| 4.451 | 4.665| 3.1 | 4.636 | 0.378| 9.37| 3.40
;;; LMI/Tyson 15-Aug-84 1920
Timing 1 Timing 2
FPRINT 17.3 (8.6) 14.9 (6.57)
;;; LMI/Carrette 9-4-84
Test MacroCompiled Microcompiled
FPRINT 6.6 LFS MCP
;;; PSL-3081
| CRAY | BPS 400K bytes| BPS 150K | BPS 150K
Benchmark | PSL 3.2| HEAP 800K bytes| HEAP 1510K | HEAP 1510K
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fprint | 3.618 | 0.334 | 0.342 | 0.342